New York’s Iconic Serendipity 3 and Its Frozen Hot Chocolate

“I first came in cos of the name… “Serendipity”… it’s one of my favorite words… It’s just such a nice sound for what it means – a fortunate accident. Except I don’t really believe in accidents, I think fate is behind everything,” says Kate Beckinsale about the legendary New York cafe Serendipity 3 in a hopelessly romantic movie – a namesake of the café – Serendipity.

I, on the other hand, have never heard the word before watching the movie but, just like Kate Beckinsale’s character, have always believed that “fate sends us little signs and it’s how we read the signs that determines whether we are happy or not”.

serendipity cafe from movie
Scene from romantic comedy “Serendipity” with John Cusack and Kate Beckinsale having frozen hot chocolate at the cafe Serendipity 3.

Boy, did I have enough and more signs to guide me through life. Sometimes I would see signs where there couldn’t be any, sometimes I would look for them relentlessly when all I really had to do was make up my mind, sometimes I would confuse random happenstances for signs. But as time passed, I learned to recognize the true signs, or at least I want to believe I did. 

If we could only see how each and every little decision changes the trajectory of our lives! Whether you turn right or left at the crossroads, whether you go to work straight away or stop by to get a cup of coffee on the way, whether you choose a night out with friends or stay at home watching movies. And if this kind of small everyday choices can influence the course of one’s life, what happens when we decide to move to a different country or get married or buy a house?

I feel myself such a tiny dot in the Universe, a very special and important dot, but still so little that it would be unbelievable to think there’s nothing beyond me. To be honest, it’s not that I cannot believe that, I simply don’t want to. I want to know that when I am lost there will be a signal showing me the right direction. You might not understand where following that sign will take you, but, to borrow a quote from the movie once again, “You don’t have to understand. You just have to have faith”. 

In most of the cases you will realize why that sign was given to you only much later. Who knows what consequences might my visit to Serendipity 3 bring? While there, I realized that the legendary New York café has a direct connection to my second home – the island of Sri Lanka – of all places! According to Serendipity 3 website, that’s how one of the owners, Patch Carradine, came up with the name “Serendipity”:

“It was Patch Carradine who found The Word that would turn their fortunes… Able to do the whole Times crossword puzzle weekly, the London Times on off days. One day he uncrossed a word that rang a bell. A word that you couldn’t find in the dictionary of common usage back in ’54. The Word was Serendipity. The art of finding the pleasantly unexpected by chance or sagacity. Invented by eighteenth century wordsmith Sir Horace Walpole, it evoked the ancient legend of the three princes of the island no longer known as Serendip.”

Guess how that island is known around the world today? Sri Lanka! Thus the name “Serendipity 3” was created. The figure 3 in the name is a reference both to three princes in the legend and to three friends who opened the café: Calvin Holt, Stephen Bruce and Patch Carradine. You can read a summary of the legend of three princes on this Wikipedia page. Funny enough, none of my friends in Sri Lanka have ever heard of it.

serendipity 3 bafore and now
The three “princes” at the doors of Serendipity 3

It took me two tries to get into the famed café. The line in front of it is much longer than five people you see in the movie. Being a naïve girl that I am, I planned to have a coffee, take some pictures and continue my marathon around NYC. Upon arrival I was greeted by a manager who proudly informed me that it’s not your regular café and people stay in line for 2-3 hours to get in. Ooops.

serendipity 3 new york
Serendipity 3 cafe today

This café is not popular because of the movie. In fact, it’s the other way around: it was chosen as a set for a movie scene because of its fame. Serendipity 3, New York’s first coffee house boutique, opened in 1954 with 4 tables, 16 chairs and Tiffany lampshades.

Some of the regulars here included Marilyn Monroe, Andy Warhol and even Jackie Kennedy. The first lady once tried to buy the recipe of Frozen Hot Chocolate – the signature dish of the café – for an event she was throwing, but Stephen Bruce refused to give it to her.

andy warhol at serendipity cafe
Andy Warhol at Serendipity 3

No wonder the wait is several hours: who wouldn’t like to sit at the table where Andy Warhol was making his first sketches? That same table is not there, of course. Neither are the Tiffany lampshades. But you feel like Alice falling into rabbit hole when the door opens and you step inside. 

serendipity interior

White walls, myriads of mirrors, gigantic clock on the wall instantly transport you into a different dimension.

serendipity 3 andy warhol favorite spot

Gorgeous colorful lampshades.

interior design details at serendipity cafe

Andy Warhol doll hanging above a table.

andy warhol serendipity

The best idea is to come here for dessert. Skip the food, which is fine, but nothing to write home about.

serendipity cafe upper east side
Those menus!

The frozen hot chocolate, on the other side, is what you must try here. Perfected over years, this drink is delectable. That’s what the characters of the movie Serendipity had after their accidental meeting and that’s what you will see on every table.

frozen hot chocolate at serendipity

If you haven’t watched the movie, here’s the scene from the cafe. Hope it will make you watch the whole thing and head down to Serendipity 3 when you visit New York!

Serendipity 3

Address: 225 E 60th St, New York, NY 10022

Hours: Mon – Sun: 11.30 AM – 12 AM

Tips: To avoid a long line, come 20-30 minutes before opening on a weekday. I came at 11.10 on Monday and was able to get in right when the café opened at 11.30.

Try the frozen hot chocolate ($8.95), it can be easily shared by two, but the café has a policy that each customer has to spend at least $8.95.

Pin for later:

the-iconic-frozen-hot-chocolate-from-serendipity-3

AUTHOR: YULIA DYUKOVA
Yulia is a Russian food and travel blogger who found home first in Sri Lanka for 3 years, then in Brazil for a year and is currently based in Austin, Texas. She is the kind of person who starts a research of the new country by googling “what to eat in…” instead of “what to visit in…” Yulia is a self-proclaimed “food nerd” who will spend hours reading on the origins of pecan pie before trying it and who doesn’t consider waiting in line of 50 people to get a cronut a waste of time. She finds it hard to keep her delicious findings to herself and that is the reason why this blog exists.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *